Fake pies

Customizable 8inch Fake Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Strawberry and Banana Cream

Customizable 8inch Fake Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Strawberry and Banana Cream

Regular price From $25.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $25.00 USD
Unit price per
Customizable Fake 8inch Traditional Pies - Pumpkin, Chocolate, Pecan and Peppermint

Customizable Fake 8inch Traditional Pies - Pumpkin, Chocolate, Pecan and Peppermint

Regular price From $25.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $25.00 USD
Unit price per
Customizable Fake 4inch Mini Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Strawberry, Pumpkin, Banana, Key Lime and Chocolate

Customizable Fake 4inch Mini Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Strawberry, Pumpkin, Banana, Key Lime and Chocolate

Regular price From $15.00 USD

Regular price Sale price From $15.00 USD
Unit price per
Customizable Fake 8inch Fruit Pies - Lemon, Key Lime, Banana and Tangerine

Customizable Fake 8inch Fruit Pies - Lemon, Key Lime, Banana and Tangerine

Regular price $25.00 USD

Regular price Sale price $25.00 USD
Unit price per

Let customers speak for us

from 128 reviews

So lLovely!

I ordered the blueberry pie and added it to my gallery wall in our kitchen. It looks so real and yummy - it brings me a lot of joy. Perfect piece of art - thank you!

Lindsay Shadili-Hadj

06/04/2025

Customizable 8inch Fake Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Strawberry and Banana Cream

The cutest!

Obsessed with this piece!

Abbey Carey

05/28/2025

Vintage Pink Fake Cake Tissue Box Holders

Looks good enough to eat

Beautiful and fun box! My partner was thrilled with it! Thank you

E K

04/22/2025

Vintage Cherry Fake Cake Boxes

Custom Order Review

I ordered a custom square tissue box from Sarah, and it's AMAZING! She was quick to get back to me about my request and was super nice about explaining the process. I did originally request to have the cherries on top swapped out for more rosettes (I was a bit surprised when I opened the box), but I actually don't mind the cherries at all. I love that the box itself is made of sturdy wood and that it's super easy to change out the tissue box (it's a great fit for standard tissue boxes). The piping is beautiful and this fake cake brings me so much joy! Thank you so much!

Grace

03/14/2025

Love!

Reached out to the owner with a couple questions & received a super quick response. She was so sweet and helpful! The item was a gift for a friend who loved it. Great experience & would totally recommend :)

AnaMarie

01/24/2025

4 Layer Fake Cake Jewelry Box

Great product

Love my grinder! Great quality and just super cute 😍 I absolutely love their art

Minerva A

10/26/2024

Fake Cake Herb/Spice Grinder

This cake got here right on my birthday! I...

This cake got here right on my birthday! Is it too early to start a Halloween collection?

Elaine

05/05/2024

CakeShackCo

Shipped fast! It is beautiful amd perfect...

Shipped fast! It is beautiful amd perfect for the baker in the family

Avery

05/04/2024

Pink and Yellow Ceramic Cake Mug

I love this! My wife enjoys wearing it for...

I love this! My wife enjoys wearing it for me.

Jeff

Vintage Fake Cake Headbands

I'm in love with this cake mug! Perfect gi...

I'm in love with this cake mug! Perfect gift to me from me. 🎂

Laura

04/30/2024

Mint and Pink Ceramic Cake Mug

It's a fun accessory but I fear it may bre...

It's a fun accessory but I fear it may break off my head from the sheer size of it. Otherwise it's a lovely gift to myself!

Janice

04/27/2024

Customizable Faux Pie Headbands

This was given as a gift for a little girl...

This was given as a gift for a little girl. She loved it! The product shipped quickly!

Kara

04/26/2024

Great service. Arrived on time and in perf...

Great service. Arrived on time and in perfect order

Charles

04/25/2024

Thank you Cake Shack! Love love my mini c...

Thank you Cake Shack! Love love my mini coconut crème pie!!

Louisa

04/24/2024

Customizable Fake 4inch Mini Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Strawberry, Pumpkin, Banana, Key Lime and Chocolate

thank you so much for all you do!

Joslan

04/21/2024

Customizable DIY Fake Cake Box Decorating Kit

Item added to your cart

Collection: Fake pies

Customizable 8inch Fake Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Strawberry and Banana Cream

Customizable 8inch Fake Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Strawberry and Banana Cream

Customizable Fake 8inch Traditional Pies - Pumpkin, Chocolate, Pecan and Peppermint

Customizable Fake 8inch Traditional Pies - Pumpkin, Chocolate, Pecan and Peppermint

Customizable Fake 4inch Mini Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Strawberry, Pumpkin, Banana, Key Lime and Chocolate

Customizable Fake 4inch Mini Pies - Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon, Strawberry, Pumpkin, Banana, Key Lime and Chocolate

Customizable Fake 8inch Fruit Pies - Lemon, Key Lime, Banana and Tangerine

Customizable Fake 8inch Fruit Pies - Lemon, Key Lime, Banana and Tangerine

Let customers speak for us